Initial Thoughts
When I was selecting cigars from a list for this review week I came across the name of the Jucy Lucy. Once I read that I knew I had try it. Mainly because the name is the same as the infamous burgers made in the Minneapolis / St. Paul area. If you’re unfamiliar with what a Jucy Lucy is, it’s a hamburger stuffed with cheese and when it’s cooked the cheese turns into liquid hot magma. It’s one of the most delicious things I’ve ever eaten. So yeah this name resonates with me a little bit.
Natural by Drew Estate is crafted using the finest Nicaraguan leaf combined with traditional black tobaccos from Syria, Turkey, St. James Parish and other exotic locales.That’s all the information it really gives about this cigar though. The Natural line comes in a lot of different sizes and shapes. In fact they the ‘Egg’ shape which is very unique, they also have a Culebra shape which you rarely see. So this line is definitely interesting and they’ve thrown everything but the kitchen sink into it. From what I’ve been able to find, this Natural Jucy Lucy has a Cameroon wrapper and is filled with Nicaraguan tobacco. I haven’t seen any official information from DE released stating that, but multiple sites are saying Cameroon, so we’ll go with that. Well I think it’s time to go ahead and hop into the review.
Looks
When I originally picked this cigar out, I was choosing from a list and had never seen it in person. Like I said I just really liked the name. Once I got the samples I was blown away at how small these little guys are. 3″x 38, yeah it sounds small until I get into my hand and I realized that was barely bigger than my pinky. I tried to show the size of these sticks by putting them next to my normal sized cutter, just as a frame of reference.
Function
Looking at the flag on this cigar I wasn’t exactly sure which approach to take to get the cigar opened. So the first round I used my capped back cutter and it took me like 5 snips to finally get the head opened up. The second time around I twisted the pulled the flag off and was then able to use the cutter right away to open up the head. I think that was probably the more efficient way. I’m just always leery to do that because I don’t want to tear the wrapper too much pulling the flag off like that.
Smoking
I didn’t really have to toast the foot on this cigar. The shaggy excess tobacco hanging over the edge makes it easy to light. Once I put my Xikar torch up to the foot it instantly lit and I was puffing away. It’s hard to break this little cigar into thirds, hell it’s hard to even break it into halves. So I’ll just talk about the whole experience. It only took me 20 minutes to smoke. The ash held on for almost an inch, but it was very flaky when it did finally fall. The burn line wasn’t razor sharp, but it never got out of control though. Overall a very pleasant smoking experience for the entirety of this Natural Jucy Lucy.
Flavor
Just how Jucy is this Lucy? Well I’m not exactly sure I would describe as ‘Jucy’ but it definitely has some interesting flavors. As I said above I instantly picked up on some flavors during the dry draw. I would say it is just packed with sweetness. A distinct molasses flavor right on the lips. Followed by some sweet tobacco notes and a hint of leather. The sweetness was similar to the Deep Dish, but not as intense.
Would I Buy It Again?
Ehh, maybe. They come in 40ct boxes, and I’m not sure if they’re sold individually.Is It an Every Day Smoke?
This certainly could be, it would be a great lunch break smoke if you need to get away.Would I Buy a Box?
I’m not sure I would, but it’s always a possibility.Frequently Asked Questions
How strong is the Natural Jucy Lucy?
The Natural Jucy Lucy is a medium to full-bodied cigar. Check our full review above for strength and body notes from first light to the nub.
What are the flavor notes of the Natural Jucy Lucy?
See the Flavor section above for a full tasting breakdown of the Natural Jucy Lucy across all three thirds, including retrohale notes and finish.
Where can I buy the Natural Jucy Lucy?
The Natural Jucy Lucy is available at Famous Smoke Shop, Cigars International, and Amazon. See the Where to Buy table below for current pricing and availability.
How much does the Natural Jucy Lucy cost?
The Natural Jucy Lucy retails for approximately $5 per stick depending on the retailer and vitola. Prices may vary by box size.
What bourbon pairs well with the Natural Jucy Lucy?
Our top bourbon pairings for the Natural Jucy Lucy are Knob Creek 9 Year, Old Forester 1920, Russell’s Reserve, chosen based on complementary flavor profile scoring. See the Pairing section below for details.
Where to Buy Natural Jucy Lucy
Average retail: ~$5 per stick. Prices vary by retailer.
| Retailer | Price | Availability | Link |
|---|---|---|---|
| Famous Smoke Shop | ~$5/stick | ✅ In Stock | Shop Now → |
| Cigars International | ~$5/stick | ⚠️ Check Stock | Shop Now → |
| Amazon (samplers) | Varies | ✅ Available | Search Amazon → |
Stogies on the Rocks may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Best Bourbon Pairings for the Natural Jucy Lucy
As a full-bodied, high-strength Nicaraguan torpedo, the Cojonu 2006 demands a bourbon with presence. Here are our top three pairings based on complementary flavor profiles.
#1 — Knob Creek 9 Year
High-rye character and oak depth complement the earthiness and spice of the Cojonu perfectly.
Buy on ReserveBar → Read Our Review →#2 — Old Forester 1920
Rich toasted oak and dark fruit lift the nutty, creamy second third beautifully.
Buy on ReserveBar → Read Our Review →#3 — Russell’s Reserve
A balanced, full-bodied pour with just enough rye spice to match the cigar’s pepper backbone.
Buy on ReserveBar → Read Our Review →Pairing suggestions based on the Stogies on the Rocks flavor profile scoring system. Browse all bourbon reviews →
Conclusion

About This Review
Eric “Siz” Scism is a Louisville, KY-based cigar and bourbon enthusiast and the founder of Stogies on the Rocks. With over 20 years of marketing experience and direct access to Kentucky’s bourbon country, Eric brings genuine expertise and a discerning palate to every review. He is also the founder of Cream of Kentucky bourbon, giving him a unique insider’s perspective on American whiskey. All cigar and bourbon reviews on this site are based on personal, unsponsored tasting experiences.

